From cuddly comforts to creative playtime essentials, these gifts bring wonder and warmth to every child’s world. Explore our handpicked non-toxic favorites — beautiful options under (or over) $50 that make mindful gifting simple.
Ages 0-5 Under $50
Curious Critter Butterfly Garden Kit $12
Do you want to teach little ones to love nature? This is the perfect hands on kit that will show them how seeds grow into flowers and feed butterflies!
Petite Collage Dress Up Magnetic Superhero Set $24
Let their imagination soar with this sustainably made, non-toxic set, and it is designed to inspire hours of creative, screen-free fun.
Wooden Rainbow Stacking Tower $45
There is a reason this toy has remained a classic for generations! Little ones love it and can learn so much (colors, hand eye coordination, fine motor skills) but because this age places everything in their mouth you REALLY want to make sure their stacking tower is 100% non toxic like this one!
My First Paint Brush Set $15
These paintbrushes are so great for little hands! Also, they are made of wood, so no worry if they end up in the mouth! A great stocking stuffer on its own or paired with some non-toxic paint!
Brainblox Natural Wooden Blocks $24
My mother has these and they have seriously entertain kids from age 3 to 16!
Plan Toys Wooden Tea Set $34
Tea parties - but make it non-toxic with this 100% wood tea set- totally safe to be placed in your little one’s mouth!
Hape Walk A Long Croc $25
Pull toys are one of the most fun toys for new walkers. These wooden ones will last forever too!
Pure Earth Collection Stuffed Animals $46
Such cute stuffed animals and organic is always better!
Hape Gourmet Kitchen Wooden Set $18
A non-toxic favorite for little chefs encouraging imaginative play while keeping materials safe and sustainable!
Le Toy Van My Doll Family $40
The size is great for any doll house and always encouraging creative play!
Ages 0-5 Over $50
Veterinary Set $54
This wooden set is perfect for any animal (real or stuffie) loving kiddo!
Melissa and Doug Solid Wood Building Blocks $65
Encourage imagination and hands-on learning with this solid wood block set from Melissa & Doug. Made to last with safe, non-toxic materials, it’s the perfect gift for creative builders.
Grimm’s Pastel Squares $118
Heirloom quality and great for boys and girls from 2 and way beyond!
Plan Toys My First Dollhouse $200
When choosing a dollhouse, solid wood it the way to go!
Reign Two Story Playhouse $4,750
Perhaps the ultimate Christmas gift….. this play structure is mostly wood and promises hours and hours of outdoor play all year round!
Apple Park Organic Doll $55
A soft, snuggly companion made from 100% organic cotton. Safe, sustainable, and oh-so-sweet — it’s the perfect toxin-free doll for little ones to love for years to come.
Earthtiles Wooden Magnatiles $87
Magnetic blocks are the type of toy that will be played with for years…. from littles to beyond the double digits…. I promise!
12-Piece Wooden Rainbow Stacking Tunnel $115
All 3 of my kids played with this toy…. and it was so well built that it still looked like new even after 11 years of on and off use! There is no end to how this open ended toy can be used (stacking, rocking chairs, for building, bridges, and so much more)… and it looks really cute in your nursery!
Wishbone Wagon 3 in 1 $450
A gift for parents and kids! It’s a classic that grows with your family
Maileg Princess Mouse and The Pea $55
If you daughter is obsessed with Maileg this is a great starter kit!
Cuddle + Kind Baby Animal Bundle $119
These stuffies are made with 100% cotton and are cute on their one. These new little “baby “ animals are just the perfect size for little hands and oh so soft and cute. My daughter sleeps with one
Micro Kickboard LED Scooter $145
Keeps the kids super active (and parents who need to run after them! and the LED lights are an extra dose of fun!)
Banwood Balance Bike $199
All my kids have had balance bikes, and my daughter has this particular one which is just so cute!
Organic Floppy Bunny Rabbit $65
Most people don’t realize that the majority of stuffed animals are made of polyester and are constantly giving off microplastics…. these are more pricey (but less, better quality, stuffed animals is not a bad idea) but they are made with organic cotton: so totally safe to snuggle with!
Sage and Wild Rug $279
These organic cotton machine washable rugs are adorable as playmate for babies, toddlers and make for a beautiful decor item in an older child’s room or playroom!
Outsunny Potting Bench Table $189
I love this wood table as an outdoor mud kitchen.
Wooden Play Kitchen $439
Made mostly from maple hardwood with some birch plywood and zero plastic, this is a dream solid wood play kitchen. Another toy that can be handed down to siblings and beyond.
These are companies and products I shop for and trust for my home, personal care, and more! Some of these links may be affiliate links, which means 3 Little Plums will receive a small commission at no additional cost to you.